You might have picked up from my post about Stephen Conroy’s plan for increasing government control of the internet by forcing an ISP level filter on us that I have an extra special contempt for the typical family values argument about the supposed need to ‘protect’ the children.
As I already stated in the previous post, if a parent wants their child protected… that is their responsibility. This applies to the Internet, and it also applies to every type of Old Media outlet. If a parent is worried about the degenerate rubbish that a child might stumble upon online, they can either supervise their child on the computer or download free filter software that doesn’t force anything on anyone else. Everyone wins. If they don’t want a child watching Jerry Springer… keep them away from the TV at the time its on… or watch another channel with them at the time… or better yet, give them a book to read or send them outside to play. Hell… take the time to calmly explain to a child why degenerate rubbish is bad… help them to understand it so they can reach that conclusion on their own rather than just having to blindly trust and obey the ‘authority figure’.
Of course, these ‘family values’ voters who want more censorship, who want more government control look like they’re too lazy to make that kind of effort as a parent… or perhaps they’re too insecure about their level of skill as parents and they feel the need for the omnipresent power of the State to charge in on a white horse and smite what they perceive to be the threat to the children.
That they would accuse those opposed to censorship of being in favour of degenerate rubbish is a clear appeal to emotion… and their most prominent emotion is fear. Its as if those who do not feel their fear are somehow in among the degenerate losers whose questionable media content is inciting this fear. There is nothing rational about it.
Of course nurturing the children is important… ensuring they grow up with as little nastiness in their lives as possible (not that easy when they’re being herded by threat of legal action into the holding pens we tend to call schools, divided by age and set down in front of a teacher who needs to be respected as the current authority figure ‘or else’). And I certainly see how constantly improving how we as a society raise our children is important in ensuring a brighter future for humanity as a whole (for the most part we’re definitely doing a better job of raising our children than our medieval Dark Age ancestors).
But for all the need to ensure our children are properly nurtured, the last thing they need is to have to be ‘protected’ but the ultimate omnipresent authority of the government. I have to ask how a child is supposed to learn to be an intelligent, responsible adult capable of managing life in a free society when they’re being constantly smothered by authority for most of their upbringing, whether it be parents, teachers, government or even ‘God’. If you want them to avoid degenerate rubbish in the media… help them to understand why it is bad… impart the knowledge upon them that will allow them to draw that conclusion on their own. There always comes a time in a person’s life where their capacity to thrive depends on their ability to make their own value judgments, and by invoking some kind of authority to censor everything robs them of the opportunity to develop those skills.
